Classic Melbourne
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Calendar
    • Terms and conditions
    • Apply to post your events
    • Post Your Event
  • Newsletter Signup
  • About
  • Contact

Melbourne Symphony Orchestra: Bartók and Beethoven

by Rosemary Richards 4th November, 2023
by Rosemary Richards 4th November, 2023
381

The Melbourne Symphony Orchestra honoured conductor Benjamin Northey’s twenty years of artistic collaboration at Monash University’s Robert Blackwood Hall on Friday night, in a repeat of the concert the previous evening at the Melbourne Town Hall. A related concert follows at the Ulumbarra Theatre in Bendigo. Ben Northey has forged a diverse international conducting career, bringing joy to players and audiences alike at home and abroad.

A fire alarm before Friday’s concert was fortunately resolved quickly. Advertised under the alliterative title “Bartók and Beethoven”, the program represented around two hundred years of musical repertoire in reverse chronological order. Deborah Cheetham Fraillon’s Acknowledgement of Country Long Time Living Here was followed by the first major work in the concert, Peter Sculthorpe’s Kakadu, a single-movement orchestral work in three sections lasting around fifteen minutes and named after the monsoonal Kakadu National Park in Australia’s north.

Premiered in the USA in Australia’s bicentennial year of 1988, Kakadu has continued to be performed since then, which is noteworthy when compared to the fate of many Australian “classical” compositions. The MSO presented the 1989 version rather than the later version with didjeridu. The acoustics in Robert Blackwood Hall melded sound colours from the strings, horns, brass, percussion and cor anglais, backed by grounding from oboes and contra bassoon, while flutes, clarinets and bassoons joined in the final burst. Sculthorpe could have been included in the promotional headlines for the concert. Today’s sensibilities may also question how indigenous some of his source material may be when divorced from its cultural and musical contexts.

Pianist Berta Brozgul, Northey and the MSO gave an inspired interpretation of Béla Bartók’s third piano concerto, composed just before the Hungarian composer’s death in 1945 in exile in the USA. This concerto deserves to be heard more frequently. Envisaged as a gift for his second wife, pianist Ditta Bartók, the concerto is more lyrical and introspective than some of Bartók’s previous compositions. The first movement’s quiet opening leads to explosions of sound but ends even more softly. The slow second movement marked “Adagio religioso” contains passages invoking Bach chorales and twilight magic. The final movement brings the concerto to an energetic close. Brozgul embodied Bartók’s music in her gestures as well as in the sounds she produced. Virtuosic demands on the solo piano throughout the concerto’s three movements were intricately interwoven with generous support from Northey and the orchestra.

After interval, the audience was treated to an expressive performance of Beethoven’s Pastoral sixth symphony, first performed in Vienna in 1808. Beethoven’s programmatic stimulus was skillfully realised by Northey and the MSO, including the dramatic transitions from country merrymaking and sudden storm to joyful thanksgiving between the third, fourth and fifth movements. The second slow movement “Scene at the brook” contains some of the many passages in this symphony that highlight the woodwinds, who received their deserved appreciation from Northey and the audience. This performance augurs well for the MSO’s forthcoming exploration of all nine Beethoven symphonies in the “Beethoven Festival” at Hamer Hall in November 2024.

It was encouraging to see that the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra can attract an enthusiastic audience in Melbourne’s southeast at Monash University’s Robert Blackwood Hall. Thanks, and best wishes for future successes are due to Ben Northey and the musicians involved in this celebratory event.

Photo credit Laura Manariti.

___________________________________________________________________________

Rosemary Richards reviewed “Bartók and Beethoven”, presented by the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra at Robert Blackwood Hall, Monash University, on November 3, 2023.

Benjamin NortheyBerta BrozgulRosemary Richards
0 FacebookTwitterLinkedinEmail
Rosemary Richards

Dr Rosemary Richards is a Melbourne-based musicologist, teacher and performer. Her research has focussed on the biographical, historical, and musical significance of memorabilia that belonged to individual musicians and their communities. With Julja Szuster, she co-edited Memories of Musical Lives: Music and Dance in Personal Music Collections from Australia and New Zealand (Lyrebird Press Australia, 2022).

Photo credit Dylan Breninger

previous post
Andrey Gugnin Recital
next post
Opera Australia: Miss Saigon

Related Posts

MSO Live at the Bowl: 50 years of ABC Classic

16th February, 2026

Melbourne Symphony Orchestra: The Voice of the Viola

9th November, 2025

Melbourne Symphony Orchestra: A Celebration of Sibelius

2nd November, 2025

Woodend Winter Arts Festival: Berta Brozgul – Variations on a...

12th June, 2025

Melbourne Symphony Orchestra: Symphonic Showcase plus Melbourne Youth Orchestra

24th February, 2025

Brunswick Beethoven Festival Concert 5: Sophia Kirsanova and Berta Brozgul

22nd February, 2025

Classic Melbourne’s reviews policy

audio
Our point of differenceby Editor Suzanne Yanko

Your browser does not support the audio element.

Follow us on Facebook

Classic Melbourne

Melbourne Arts Centre

Melbourne Arts Centre

Melbourne Recital Centre

Melbourne Recital Centre

Introducing Classic Melbourne

audio
Speech at launch by Conductor Andrew Wailes

Your browser does not support the audio element.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

@2019 - All Right Reserved.

Classic Melbourne
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Calendar
    • Terms and conditions
    • Apply to post your events
    • Post Your Event
  • Newsletter Signup
  • About
  • Contact

Read alsox

Songs of the Latin Skies

5th July, 2017

The Australian Ballet: Oscar

15th September, 2024

Don Giovanni: two reviews

13th May, 2015